My 17 yr old daughter wanted red boots in a bad way. She was so excited when she opened them for Christmas, however we have had to return them due to how they fit. The length of the boot is true to size, however the shaft is very wide and was "floppy" when she walked. Granted she is 5ft 10 and 125# and has very thin legs. Much to her disappointment we have had to return these beautiful boots and replace them with boots that have a narrow shaft. Still very nice boots.