I initially ordered this shoe in my regular size whic h is 9. When I received the shoe, it was HUGE! My foot literally swam in it! So...I reorderd the shoe in 1/2 size smaller. That size 8 1/2 fits evry well. There is still room at the toe, however this is to be expected as the toe is extended and very slim. BEWARE...if the shoe is the wrong size and you need to return it, Overstock will charge you for the return label. I hope this policy changes as it will keep me from orderiing shoes and clothing from this company. I'm not sure why they charge from return shipping as all companies I order from...****, ****, etc. have free return shipping. When I spoke to the customer service rep, she seemed to be shocked to learn that other companies had free return shipping. She also seemed to think that Overstock wasn't aware that other companies had this service. Whatever.