I have to say, being first time buyers on Overstock and having limited online purchasing experience, this was an amazing experience for us. We ordered two matching rings (his and hers). They arrived quickly (in about 5 days) and looked exactly as advertised. They have a great weight and feel, and we're very happy with them. We followed the advice from other reviews and ordered a 1/2 size smaller, and turned out they fit perfectly. We love the rings. For the price, it's hard to find anything that compares in value.