I'll give it 2 stars because it feels sturdier than I thought it would, but it's still a cheap looking and feeling cabinet. The finish on it comes off just by looking at it funny. The shelves are flimsy and pitiful. The color is pretty dark, which was fine. The crappy shelves they do give you aren't nearly enough if you want to store CDs instead of DVDs. A ton of wasted space. It also requires you put the lock in whether you want it or not because there's a hole drilled for it. Sadly I know what a PITA returning something to Overstock is, so it looks like I'm stuck with it and out *****.