We both love the pillows. We added a new guest room and I bought a lot of new bedding including 2 pair of these pillows. We love ours and so far the guests who have slept on the other set have had good things to say about them too. They are thick and fluffy and the feathers are so comfortable to lay your head on, not all lumpy like foam can get. If you are a feather bedding person, you will love these!