The leather, size and finish on the tray are very nice. However, the plastic feet were cracked and smashed. There didn't seem to be any damage to the outside of the box, I think it's the way these things are packaged. I had bought two and pried the feet out of one ottoman so one has the un-damaged feet in it, othe other one I used the feet from the ottomans we were replacing and put them on the bottom. I just didn't want to deal with the hassle of exchanging. It's pretty heavy to move, so it does need some plastic feet on the botttom if you want to be able to move it on a carpet.