I gave it 3 stars because they are comfortable, but quality leaves much to be desired. These boots were what I've been looking for. I bought them about 2 years ago and never bothered to write a review. The heel height is perfect and I like to wear them especially on rainy days or when the weather is cold. The one thing I don't like about the boots is that the toe can be easily scraped. I wore it to work once and had to plug in something under my desk. I bent my knees in a way that the toe area accidentally touched the carpet (we have the rough office-type carpet) and little did I know that the thin black film that covers whatever the boot is made out of got scraped and I could see grey under it. I was so sad, as that was like the third time I ever wore those boots and they took me a long time to find; I had to use a black sharpie to hide the grey. The problem now is that the toe part does not have the glossy finish the rest of the shoe has. After that happened, I decided I won't buy any more man-made leather (or whatever it's called) and just buy real leather. If you buy these boots, make sure you don't get them scraped at all.
- Please tell us about the quality of the product. Quality is so-so, as most typical man-made materials are.