Free Shipping on EVERYTHING!* 

Old Sesame Street Toys

Reviews of Top Products

Gund Sesame Street 50th Anniversary Elmo Stuffed Animal Plush, 20in
"not what I expected" by Shari C.

It's a Nice soft doll but expected a plushier one from Gund for the price. I am keeping because it is my Grandson's favorite character

Show MoreCaret Down
10
GUND Sesame Street Bert Plush, 14"
"Great plush Sesame Street stuffed toys...." by mosesxena

All children will love this Sesame Street plus toy. Bert is 14 ins tall, soft and bendable. It made a wonderful gift. Purchased he’s friend Ernie also. A great addition for any child who loves Sesame Street....

Show MoreCaret Down
4
Kiddieland Sesame Street Elmo's Plane Light and Sound Activity Ride-on
Review by ezemu

My babies love it. Never had a problem with it. We have had it for almost a year, and it is still intact.

Show MoreCaret Down
5
Gund Sesame Street Ernie Plush Toy
"Bert’s best friend...." by mosesxena

See my review on Bert...purchased together. Great gift....

Show MoreCaret Down
8
Playskool Friends Sesame Street Cookie Monster Mini Plush
Review by Jacqueline R.

Just the right size to carry around..grandson loves him.

Show MoreCaret Down
1
Funko POP! Sesame Street Specialty Series Herry Monster Vinyl Figure
Review by Cindy T.

Herry Monster is fine. He just scared my daughter. I would not recommend if you have small children. Even if they love Sesame Street. Happy with packaging and shipping

Show MoreCaret Down
1
GUND Sesame Street Cookie Monster 12" Plush
Review by Jennifer H.

Very cute and well made. Would buy another Gund stuffed animal

Show MoreCaret Down
17
Sesame Street Cookie Monster Character 12" Plush - Multi
Review by Derek

My niece loves cookie monster she happy it for search long time find this stuff toy for her. Thanks again Overstock well done job.

Show MoreCaret Down
1
Sesame Street Play Town Learning Curve Real Wood 2pk Grover & Elmo - Multi
Review by tpfern

My grandson loved these sesame street characters. They're chunky and perfect for his little hands. I have never seen these anywhere else and several other mothers have inquired as to where these were purchased. These little character toys were a hit and are a quality product. Thank you for offering these for purchase.

Show MoreCaret Down
4
Sesame Street Elmo Character 13" Plush - Multi
Review by erosenbe

loved the fuzziness the face, the feel, the color; my grandson loved this and carries it everywhere!

Show MoreCaret Down
1
Sesame Street Elmo and Dorothy 4 Inch BFF Plush Set - Red
"Her new favorite!!!!" by Kimberly F.

These are super tiny, designed to fit into a toddlers hand, so if you are expecting a bigger stuffed animal this isn’t it. But this is my toddler’s third “best friend” set from Sesame Street and this was just an awesome addition to her collection. She LOVES them!

Show MoreCaret Down
1
Sesame Street Neighborhood Friends Includes 5 Figures, 3-Inches, Classic Collectibles Pack For Toddlers, Great Toy For
Review by Sara F.

Our little grandson is turning two. He loves Elmo and all of the Sesame Street characters. We ordered these adorable little figures for his two year old birthday party to decorate his cupcakes with. Then he can play with them in the tub, pool, and with his cars and trucks. They really are stinking cute. A lot cuter than they look in the picture. Also, there are no little pieces that can break away and cause chocking.

Show MoreCaret Down
1