American Coin Treasures 1859 First Year of Issue Indian Head Penny Collection

by American Coin Treasures
Was: $37.99
Free Shipping*

Start your free 30-day Club O Rewards trial today!

Free Shipping
Free Shipping
on every purchase you make
Earn Rewards Back
Rewards for Purchases
when you shop at Overstock
Free Returns
Free, No-Hassle Returns
on select clothing, shoes & jewelry
Rewards for Reviews
Rewards for Reviews
when you tell us what you think
Additional Perks
Additional Perks
on hotels, dining, and more
ITEM# 14741398
  • Delivery Estimate

    Select a Product Option to view shipping

      **Delivery date is approximate and not guaranteed. Estimates include processing and shipping times, and are only available in US (excluding APO/FPO and PO Box addresses). Final shipping costs are available at checkout.

    • Warranty
      Included: 1 year Manufacturer
    • Notifications

      Receive product notifications for this item, and also receive other email-exclusive savings.

    Love this item?

    Save it to a list so you can find it anytime!


    something went wrong.

    Please refresh the page and try again.


    ITEM#: 14741398

    The Indian Head Cent, struck from 1859 to 1909, and designed by James Barton Longacre is one of America's most popular coins and is housed in a beautiful blue display box. You can now own the first year of issue Indian Head Cent.

    • Brand: American Coin Treasures
    • 1859 First Year of Issue Indian Head Penny Collection
    • Model: 11390
    • Designed by James Barton Longacre
    • Housed in a beautiful blue display box
    • Certificate of Authenticity is included
    • Materials: Cardboard/satin/coins
    • Dimensions: 2.625 inches high x 3.187 inches wide x 1.25 inches deep


    Dimensions See description
    Warranty 1 year Manufacturer
    Model Number 11390
    Country of Origin United States
    • nice coin but not worth the money
      Verified Purchase

      Nice coin but not worth the money. The coin looks very nice and is in good condition, but there is no reason for it to be this expensive.

      Read More
    • Indian Cent
      Verified Purchase

      A great first year issue Indian Head Cent in a hansom case.

      Read More

    Questions & Answers

    • Q:

      "This was my first time on this site.Why is this coin so overpriced?I have an N.G.C. graded 1859 Indian Head penny that graded out at AU-58 and did not pay this much for my coin.I hope this is not what I this site is all about."

      • A:

        Hello swampdonkeykevin, we pride ourselves in our low prices and check to make sure our prices a competitive. Please let us know if you have additional questions about this 1859 First Year of Issue Indian Head Penny. Thanks for shopping with us!

    • Q:

      "In what condition is the coin? Does it have scratches? Is it in excellent, very good, good, or fair condition? Do you have any uncirculated 1859 INdian Head pennies? Thank you."

      • A:

        The coin is in very good condition. Unfortunately, we do not have any uncirculated 1859 Indian Head pennies. Thank you.

    Shipping & Returns

    Contact Information


    Usually leaves our warehouse in 1-2 business days. *

    Shipping Information:

    Our standard shipping method is ground shipping. We also offer expedited shipping for most items. Your final shipping cost and estimated delivery timeframe will be available at checkout.
    Standard shipping details
    Expedited shipping details

    Standard Return Policy:

    Items must be returned in new or unused condition and contain all original materials included with the shipment. For the return policy on a Marketplace item, please refer to the Seller’s individual policy, located on the product page by clicking on the Seller name. More Details

    FINAL SALE EXCLUSION: Items marked as FINAL SALE are not returnable unless the problem you experience is the result of our error.

    For your protection, all orders are screened for security purposes. If your order is selected for review, our Loss Prevention Team may contact you by phone or email. There may be a two business day delay to process your order.

    ** Most Oversize orders are delivered within 1-4 weeks. Some orders may take 6 weeks to be delivered.