Reviews Overview
Write a Review
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Stars

Read All Montebello 14k White Gold 1/2ct TDW Certified Diamond Stud Earrings (F-G, SI2) Reviews

Filter By:
  • All Ratings
  • 5 Star
  • 4 Star
  • 3 Star
  • 2 Star
  • 1 Star
Sort By:
Most Recent
  • Rating: High-Low
  • Rating: Low-High
  • Most Helpful
  • Most Recent
  • Exactly What I Expected
    Verified Purchase

    I purchased these earrings for my wife on our anniversary. I recently moved to a small town with no established jewelers. After spending days online researching diamonds and grading criteria, I felt confident in my abilities to purchase a 'decent' pair of diamonds. Anyone can provide a 'flexible grade' to diamonds, but don't always believe what you read. I am no diamond grading expert but I did expect to receive a pair of relatively clear, little to no yellow diamonds. I received exactly what was graded and an very pleased with my purchase. Gift them to the wife tomorrow and I already know she'll be thrilled.

    Read More
  • Very nice, but description is inaccurate.
    Verified Purchase

    I bought these for my wife. My initial impression is that I am very satisfied with the product, although I haven't removed them from the black earring case. However, there are two inaccuracies on the product page. The diamonds are not 4mm across, although I thought that might be the case since the description also states the entire earring (including prongs) is 4mm across. However, this is actually a good thing, because a .25 carat princess diamond would have to be cut way too shallow to be that wide, thus causing a loss of sparkle. My certificate states the dimensions as 3.21 x 3.32 mm (which is a 1.034 length to width ratio). Now, on the topic of the certification, it is not from "IGL" as stated in the description. Rather, the certification is from Independent Gemological Laboraties, which does not go by its initials IGL. You can search them online and see they are different certification companies. Also, the cerificate only gives a single set of dimensions and ratings, even though there are 2 distinct diamonds. Perhaps they report the average? The report further explains the diamonds were graded after mounting, and the .50 CTTW is "estimated by formula." Confirming an FAQ response from O, the reported polish and symmetry are both "v. good." Finally the gold earring itself looks to be of very high quality, not overly thin like some jewelry.

    Read More
  • Very Happy
    Verified Purchase

    I was very happy with these earrings, got them for my daughter for Christmas and she just loved them. They came in a really cute box and the earings were of very good quality very pretty with a really nice sparkle. I almost bought a pair just like them for almost twice the price at a popular retail store but then I decited to check Overstock and found these and purchased them right away and needless to say it was a great buy.

    Read More
  • Great quality
    Verified Purchase

    These are beautiful diamonds, clear to the eye, great cut so they sparkle nicely! A bargain for the price.

    Read More
  • Very nice set
    Verified Purchase

    The color on the EGL certification says these are E-F color. I asked a couple of jewelers what they thought the color on these earrings were and they responded G which is still really good. These are beautiful earrings and at a good price. Would purchase again if I had to.

    Read More
  • Not the stand-out earrings I was looking for....
    Verified Purchase

    I wanted sparkly, clear, well-cut diamonds. Was very disappointed with these- they were not sparkly at all and just very average-looking. . I thought that based on the color and clarity ratings and the certification these would be awesome, but I was not wowed. I'm sure for the price, they are a good value- just not what I was looking for. Will be returning and saving money until I can buy diamonds with more sparkle...probably in-person instead of online.

    Read More
  • good all around
    Verified Purchase

    I was very nervous about buying diamonds and did a lot of research, including walking into shops and looking at what was available. Once I understood the rating system, I realized that the certified diamonds of the quality offered by Overstock were a real value. These earrings are the perfect size for a young woman who is not dressing for galas numerous times a year. They are beautiful and can be worn with any outfit although wonderful enough for very special occasions too.

    Read More
  • Beautiful!!
    Verified Purchase

    Got these diamond studs as a first anniversary gift from my hubby! Needless to say, we had shopped a lot, both in stores and online. We could not find stones of a comparable quality at even twice the price. Moreover, the EGL certification was reassuring. The earrings themselves are very nice, and the size, just right for everyday wear. Subtle, elegant, and beautiful!!!

    Read More
  • Verified Purchase

    Read More
Sponsored Links