Sealy Extra Firm 300 Thread Count Side Sleeper Pillow (Set of 2)

by Sealy
Sale Starts at$3509
Free Shipping*

Plus, Free Shipping & 5% Rewards back for only $19.95/yr Learn More




5% Rewards

On Every Order

Free Shipping

On Every Order

Exclusive Rewards

Earn Big - Up to 40% back!

Free Returns

On Select Clothing & Shoes

Exclusive Offers

Straight to Your Email Inbox

5% Dining Rewards

Get Paid to Go Out Tonight

ITEM# 17644040
  • Delivery Estimate

    Select a Product Option to view shipping

      **Delivery date is approximate and not guaranteed. Estimates include processing and shipping times, and are only available in US (excluding APO/FPO and PO Box addresses). Final shipping costs are available at checkout.

    • Warranty
      Included Warranty: 1 year Limited Manufacturer
    • Notifications

      Receive product notifications for this item, and also receive other email-exclusive savings.

    Love this item?

    Save it to a list so you can find it anytime!


    something went wrong.

    Please refresh the page and try again.

    Made in USA


    ITEM#: 17644040

    This handy pack of two classic pillows from Sealy features an extra-firm density and hypoallergenic fill that is perfect for side sleepers. Made with 300 thread count cotton sateen fabric and satin trim gussets, these pillows are machine washable for easy care. 

    • White cotton fabric with a polyester fill
    • Set includes 2 bed pillows
    • For side sleepers
    • Extra-firm support
    • 300 thread count
    • Hypoallergenic
    • Satin trim gussets
    • Machine washable

    • Standard: 18 inches wide x 24 inches long (22 oz. fill)
    • King: 18 inches wide x 34 inches long (32 oz. fill)

    The digital images we display have the most accurate color possible. However, due to differences in computer monitors, we cannot be responsible for variations in color between the actual product and your screen.


    Care Instruction Machine Wash
    Country of Origin United States
    Fill Type Polyester
    Pillow Firmness Extra Firm
    Pillow Material Cotton, Polyester
    Pillow Type Bed
    Product Features Hypoallergenic, Made in USA
    Set Includes Set of 2
    Dimensions See details
    Warranty 1 year Limited Manufacturer
    Model Number DOW555PG0040
    Country of Origin United States

    Customer Reviews

    5 Stars
    4 Stars
    3 Stars
    2 Stars
    1 Stars
    • Most Recent

    • Very firm
      Verified Purchase

      I love a firm pillow, this is very firm.

      Read More
      adriennes Jan 15, 2018
    • Restfull
      Verified Purchase

      It's hard to find a good pillow, aways hit or miss. These are perfect for me!

      Read More
      Cynthia F. Jan 10, 2018
    • Bang for the Buck. Proven
      Verified Purchase

      This is by a very reputable Brand. It's firm but i wouldnt say it's Extra. Im a side sleeper and it's perfect. No pains and I would definitely bnuy again! Great pricing too!!! Better then a cheap local one without a doubt!

      Read More
      Kazuyoshi O. Dec 31, 2017
    • How is this extra firm?
      Verified Purchase

      This item is listed as extra firm but it's more like extra soft. It compresses down to two inches high when I lay my head on it so it's barley higher than the top of the mattress. I definitely would not recommend this to others!!! Waste of money. My fault for buying a pillow online,.. never again!

      Read More
      ericke w. Dec 29, 2017
    • Comfy
      Verified Purchase

      This is very cozy. We love having it for our bed.

      Read More
      a110scoach Dec 24, 2017
    • Most Helpful

    • Just firm enough for a side sleeper like me.
      Verified Purchase

      I'm really picky when it comes to my pillow. My husband can sleep on most anything and get a good night's rest. Our pillows were to the "staying in the folded position" toss time. I did some research and liked what I read about these Sealy Extra Firm 300 Thread Count pillows. Excited to find a set of them on Overstock, I ordered them. I wanted us to sleep on them a few weeks before leaving a review. I'm very impressed and pleased! My husband likes his, too. These are not extra firm in the sense of being hard and "bouncy". I can turn and move easily and comfortably; my neck isn't stiff and sore. As a side sleeper, I don't like my face buried in a pillow to where I can't breathe. These pillows are a tad shorter than most standard pillows. That doesn't bother me, but you might want to know. They are thicker than my other pillows. The thread count feels amazing. I can definitely tell the difference that thread count makes. I have no reservations in recommending these pillows.

      Read More
      Carla S. Feb 1, 2016
    • Nice and firm
      Verified Purchase

      Pillows are soft to the touch, plump & firm, which is exactly what I wanted. They are great for side sleepers.

      Read More
      hemi2 Feb 20, 2016
    • Cuddle Soft
      Verified Purchase

      My favorite pillow and I have tried them all. The inner stuffing is like fluffy silk, no hard places.

      Read More
      ecarmo Nov 10, 2015
    • pillows
      Verified Purchase

      I would have given these a 5-star, but they sleep hot.

      Read More
      veeper31 Feb 18, 2016
    • Love my new pillows!
      Verified Purchase

      I'm a side sleeper and my old pillow needed replacement. Bought these because they come in a package of 2 and it was a great purchase. Firm, big (king size), awesome!

      Read More
      PRican61 Nov 17, 2015

    Questions & Answers

    • Q:

      "Is this the king or standard size?"

      Have an Answer? Be the first to answer this question!
    • Q:

      "I am a side sleeper. I need a really firm pillow that does not go flat in a couple of months. Does this pillow meet this requirement? Thank you."

      • A:

        This pillow is not extra firm at all. It is actually quite soft. I am a side sleeper and use extra firm pillows. This is not the pillow you want. I continue to search for a truly extra firm pillow. Hope this helped!

      • A:

        I agree with Kathy. This is not an extra firm pillow. I suggest you keep looking.

      • A:

        Thank you for your response! I appreciate your honesty. I will continue my search...

      • A:

        This pillow went flat in the center for me.

      • A:

        I was tired of buying pillows that would go flat within a matter of weeks so I thought if I spent a little more maybe just maybe these pillows would last. They are the best pillows I have ever bought!

      • A:

        Yes it does. It is larger than I anticipated. But I now really love it. I didn't realize that a larger pillow would be so comfortable for me. I am also a side sleeper.

      • A:

        I am a side sleeper and I still use my arm under the pillow to get comfortable. It's definitely too soft for me to not have the extra support but overall is holding its shape and my main pillow. It hasn't flattened for me but if you're looking for really firm, try something else.

      • A:

        No it does not. I had Sealy extra firm with pink gusseted sides (these looked identical in photo) previously, these are not close. They are not extra firm, they are medium-to-soft at best. They are shorter and fatter than the original rectangular shaped items.. After two weeks it already has a "dent" in the middle. Very disappointed with these, they don't represent the brand well at all. I paid the extra to get Sealy quality but these are a poor knock off.

      Read more Read less
    • Q:

      "Why did you choose this product?"

      • A:

        I want an extra firm pillow (that is also a side-sleeper pillow) that can be laundered in the washing machine, and since I trust the Sealy name, I am expect I'll be pleased with this purchase. Because I'm Club O Gold customer, the free (and quick!) shipping that Overstock offers is great for a bulky purchase like this. It's a win-win scenario.

      • A:

        trying to find a pillow I can sleep on, thread count plus extra firm caught my attention

      • A:

        Because we need new pillows. We are both side sleepers

      • A:

        Replacing current old firm king size pillows.

      • A:

        Being a side-sleeper, it is difficult to find a firm enough pillow, I trust the Sealy name, and decided to give these a chance.

      • A:

        I've been looking for a good pillow and this one received good reviews.

      • A:

        It's my favorite pillow ever!

      • A:

        I love these pillows and they help me sleep so much better. I even take 1 with me when I travel.

      • A:

        test it out

      • A:

        The extra firm and side sleeper combination plus the reviews.

      • A:

        This is my 2nd pr of these pillows. They are extra firm but are perfect for my sleep requirements. They do not lose they're shape. Very good for this price.

      • A:

        A recent guest was impressed with the pillows I already have. I decided to gift her with them.

      • A:

        I have bought these pillows before and really like them. I have neck problems and they help with that.

      • A:

        Extra firm description and price

      • A:

        Made in the USA

      • A:

        The description suited my current needs perfectly.

      • A:

        I chose this item because of the name brand and price.

      • A:

        Need new pillow and it’s a side sleeper pillow

      • A:

        I bought these to replace my old side sleeper pillows. Very good price!

      • A:

        I have owned these in the past and was searching for replacements for our master bedroom! Hopefully they will stand up to the same wear and tear as there predecessors! Love and trust the brand.

      Read more Read less

    Shopping Tips & Inspiration

    Shipping & Returns

    Contact Information

    Usually leaves our warehouse in 1-2 business days. *

    Shipping Information:

    Our standard shipping method is ground shipping. We also offer expedited shipping for most items. Your final shipping cost and estimated delivery timeframe will be available at checkout.
    Standard shipping details
    Expedited shipping details

    Standard Return Policy:

    Items must be returned in new or unused condition and contain all original materials included with the shipment. More Details

    FINAL SALE EXCLUSION: Items marked as FINAL SALE are not returnable unless the problem you experience is the result of our error.

    For your protection, all orders are screened for security purposes. If your order is selected for review, our Loss Prevention Team may contact you by phone or email. There may be a two business day delay to process your order.

    ** Most Oversize orders are delivered within 1-4 weeks. Some orders may take 6 weeks to be delivered.