I would have rated it an 'excellent' except that the solder between the glass was a bit sloppy in parts. Not noticeable until you are close up to it. I was surprised that there were very light green and pink tones in the white glass pieces on the bottom. It might be noticeable if the chandelier is at eye level... very subtle tho. The 'diamonds' sparkle and add an elegance to it. The blue tones between the diamonds is just as pictured. We replaced one of the can lights in the ceiling of the kitchen, right in front of the window, with this. I have not put it to the test of whether it gives enough task light at night. I put 2 energy efficient bulbs in it. We'll see.