I gave this ring 4 stars because it is very nice looking. Keep in mind it is only 10k gold and not very expensive. It is not the most comfortable ring but once I got used to it I thought it was ok. The band is thin and has some hard edges. I wanted a diamond ring that was not too flashy for "every day" wear and I think this was perfect. It is very pretty and everyone I showed it to really liked it. It is simple and elegant looking. I would recommend it if you are just looking for a decent priced diamond ring that looks nice.