Ordered these as a Christmas gift for my husband. They were very reasonably priced but they are mismatched. Three of them are hammered copper and one is smooth. The price prevents me from going through the hassle of returning them. Otherwise the quality is quite nice. Oh...one more thing, most won't find this a problem but these mugs are HUGE. I mean you better be light on the vodka or you will be three sheets after one mule with these mugs.