I ordered this ring as a gift for my girlfriend for the holidays. Got a great price, there are comparable rings at **** for around ***. The only difference was the ring they were selling had an extra diamond, but they were both the same 1/4ct TDW. I asked her what she would rate the ring, and she said a 4 as well. The only thing I don't like about is that one of the diamonds was a little cloudier/darker than the rest. I am not an expert, but it was noticeable to me after looking at the ring a few times. To be honest, you can't find a better deal either online or in stores. I would recommend.