I gave these boots 3 stars for an Overall Rating but only because I own a couple of pair of UGGS and comparing them there is no contest; Its like comparing apples and oranges. Now with that said, they may not be the same quality as the UGGS (lets just say 'you get what you pay for), I love these boots!!They are 5 stars in almost every other category! The price is great and while they dont have quite the cushion of the UGGS they are great! I waterproofed them and can wear them through the season w/ no worries, chuck them at the end and get another pair next year! Like i said, these boots are definitely worth the price!! I may get them in every color!