I thought these boots looked great online. I have ordered from Overstock before and never had a problem, so I didn't hesitate as they seemed like a great deal. I wear a 7.5 and sometimes 8, so I ordered the 8 thinking there would be plenty of room with socks for winter, etc. There is no way this is a true 8. They feel like 7s and my toes are at the end with no socks on!! Honestly, for fit I gave them one star---I would have given zero stars if that were an option--that's how off they are. Also, this is an example of you get what you pay for. At first glance, they are cute, but they seem pretty flimsy, the lining is not very think, and when I shoved my feet into them, it felt like the soles were so stiff, they wouldn't even bend---kind of like walking on cardboard. Needless to say, I"m returning them. Another reviewer pointed out that when they get wet, the water soaks through, so what good is that? I wish I had read more reviews of them before I made my purchase a few weeks ago. I'm sorry I can't recommend them bc again, they are cute and stylish at first glance.