I had purchased another winder on Overstock and it still wouldn't allow my watch to keep time. I guess it didn't move enough. After two years it died. I have had this one for two weeks and my watch has kept perfect time. I like that the insert keeps the watch in place. There are two inserts, one for a woman's watch and one for a man. It is quite. You can change the direction of the winder. I am very pleased with the product.