THE BASICS: Bought these for 75-inch doors that open onto a deck. It gets cold in Summit County, CO, so I've been looking for curtains that can insulate when it gets down to negative temperatures. As I just hung them, can't say how they perform on that front, but fabric seems heavy enough to keep the cold out. SIZE: I've heard it said that you need to buy curtains that are 2.5 times the size of the window being covered. Perhaps, but I like that these cover the windows with a little left to spare, and the rest of the time, hang without a lot of bulk on either side of the window. FEATURES: Antique brass grommets were tough to match with a curtain rod, so ended up buying solid black with fun finial from overstock.com. Dislike the plastic end, but no one can tell. Antique brass looks great with black. COLOR: These were true to color, something I was very nervous about. They blend into the rest of the room while adding a bit of elegance to the decor. ALSO: These come with pull-backs, as noted. Not sure others I was looking at do. Nice to have this, but keep in mind you have to purchase hooks to attach pull back to BOTTOM LINE: Really like these so far, particularly compared to Themalogic ones purchased from Sierra Trading Post. Cheaper, yes, but definitely noticeable that they cost less. If only can find these in size I need for the other windows!

• How did the color on site compare with the actual product? spot on
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. fabric is soft and elegant, hangs nicely
• How accurate was the on site description of the product? spot on