When we received this item the outside of the case was heavily scratched, hinge on the cover was broken and several of the pods holding the eye shadows had come loose and had fallen out. It could have happened during shipping but that does not account for the scratches on the cover since all the packaging was intact and appeared in good shape. This was intended as a gift but since it was in such bad shape my wife kept it for her own use. She said that the color assortment was good but the quality as just okay. If it had arrived in better shape I would have given it three stars.