Initially very pleased with these pillows -- time will tell if they wear well and keep their loft, but so far, I am impressed with their loft and the uniformity of the down filling. They fill a pillowcase nicely and shake quickly back into full plumpness. My husband and I have radically different wants for pillows -- I sleep on my side and prefer support. He sleeps on his back and wants the thinnest pillow possible. These pillows are working for both of us; I punch mine up, he mashes his down :) He has not been a fan of down before this, preferring the cheapest poly pillows ever, and I have despaired of ever having nice-looking pillows on the bed. These may be changing his mind -- let's all hope, anyway.