I'm not sure what a *bad* horse shoe set would look like...but we're very happy with this one. Nice quality, looks good, hasn't broken, and love the carrying case. The only downside for me was the big "made in China" stamped on the horseshoes.

• How accurate was the sizing? accurate
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. good quality
• Was the product free of any manufacturer defects? yes

This set was a great buy as it is very heavy and durable. Our family played all day on Father's Day and had everyone loved it. It will now be a family tradition. Shipping is always so reasonable with Overstock. Thanks

Great gift and easy to set up. The horseshoes are high quality and well balanced

• Was the product free of any manufacturer defects? yes

Very nice set of horseshoes. My son in law loved them and can't wait to use them. He said " they are so nice I might just hang them on the wall." I was impressed.

• How accurate was the sizing? Perfect
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. Very Nice
• Was the product free of any manufacturer defects? Yes

This was a gift for my son and they think the quailty was great.