I'd give it overall 4 and a half stars.
First, It comes in 5 boxes. 2 of the boxes did not come in great shape. One was torn open, and I found a few washers and a bolt in my driveway.
Getting past that, we made room to set this baby up. Left with quite a bit of cardboard and styrofoam, but hey you gotta protect the goods.
We starting putting together, and had two pieces that woudln't fit. The main piece which fits to the long support that holds the seat. The hole was bent in a little so "A" wouldn't fit into "B", we had to use a crowbar to pry the hole open enough so that they'd fit.
After that, everything went smooth. Directions were very clear, and things fit together nicely.
Appreance is sweet. Very sharp machine.
Durabilty - well its early yet. I weigh around 275lbs and I have no issues with things bending, creaking, or an instability.
The cables used flow smoothly - more than any other gym I've used.
Price is - well fairly steep. Going through Bowflex would have cost me an extra grand though, so Overstock was a great option. My friend who helped set up said "this thing is slick!" several times. My response each time was "it should be for what I paid!". But hey you pay for qulaity.
It's early yet, but I really like it.