American Coin Treasures 1800's Rare Coin Collection

Included Warranty: 1 year Manufacturer
The Rewards Program that Pays for Itself
  • EARN 5 to 40%
    Earn 5% in Club O Rewards on every order & up to 40% on select items.
  • FREE SHIPPING Every Order, Every Day*
    No matter how big or small, your order always ships for free.
    Dedicated customer service and early access to exclusive deals.
    Club O pays for itself, or we make up the difference
Today: $18.89
At other retailer: $25.03 Save $6.14 (25%)
ITEM# 13712062
  • Delivery Estimate

    Select a Product Option to view shipping

    • Product Alerts

      Stay in the know! Choose which alerts you’d like to receive on this product.

    American Coin Treasures 1800's Rare Coin Collection
    • Wishlists
    • Save for Later


    ITEM#: 13712062

    Enjoy the American history that lies in this rare 1800's coin set. The US genuine two coin set includes an Indian Head penny and a Liberty Head nickel.

    • Brand: American Coin Treasures
    • Indian Head penny depicts a Liberty in a war bonnet (1859-1909)
    • Liberty Head nickel with 13 stars (1883-1912)
    • Certificate of authenticity is included


    Dimensions see product description
    Warranty 1 year Manufacturer
    Materials see product description
    Model Number 1634

    Customer Reviews

    5 Stars
    4 Stars
    3 Stars
    2 Stars
    1 Stars
    • Coins

      Coins were of poor condition. I didnt care about the nickle, I ordered because it was implied that the "Liberty" would be visible on the Indian head penny. Price for both coins way over cull price.

      Read More
    • chipped coin

      The product was very disappointing. The nickel was chipped and is worthless. One would think that Overstock would inspect the product before shipping it out. My daughter was very disappointed when she saw the poor quality of the nickel.

      Read More
    • Very nice set.

      I bought this as a gift for my father who is a coin collector. Very nice.

      Read More
    • Coin's only worth ***/coin's very worn out!

      The quality of the coin's are so poor that you can hardly tell anything about them.I paid *** for 2 coin's that are worth about ***.This was my first time buying from this site,and it will be my last.DO NOT WASTE YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY ON THIS PRODUCT!!!! I will never buy anything else from this company.I could have got 2 really nice coin's off of Ebay for ***.

      Read More

    Questions & Answers

    Get your product questions answered right here.
    • What are the grades/conditions of these coins? I am very interested in these coins and others sold by Overstock, but it's hard to spend money on them when Overstock neglects to mention their condition or grade, such as BU, Uncirculated, VF, Good, etc. For instance, an Indian Head penny in BU grade goes for more than one in good condition. One in poor or worn condition is probably worth a penny. So in the ad, please mention the grades of the coins that would be sent. Thank you very much.

      • Thank you for your inquiry. Unfortunately the coins in this item are not graded and have been circulated. We apologize for the inconvenience.

    Shopping Tips & Inspiration

    Shipping & Returns


    Usually leaves our warehouse in 1-2 business days. *

    Standard Return Policy:

    Items must be returned in new or unused condition and contain all original materials included with the shipment. More Details

    FINAL SALE EXCLUSION: Items marked as FINAL SALE are not returnable unless the problem you experience is the result of our error.

    Shipping Information:

    Our standard shipping method is ground shipping. We also offer expedited shipping for most items. Your final shipping cost and estimated delivery timeframe will be available at checkout.
    Standard shipping details
    Expedited shipping details

    * For your protection, all orders are screened for security purposes. If your order is selected for review, our Loss Prevention Team may contact you by phone or email. There may be a two business day delay to process your order.

    ** Most Oversize orders are delivered within 1-4 weeks. Some orders may take 6 weeks to be delivered.