When I opened the box, the makers of Stuhrling Original try to induce the new buyer to receive an extended warranty in exchange for writing positive reviews on Overstock.com. FACT. This was a red flag, but I was determined to have an open mind. In month 3, the second hand fell off. I had coincidentally scratched the pretty face a little, and asked the operator to kindly buff the face when they repaired the broken second hand. This technically threw me outside the warranty, and I paid $55 to have the defective second hand replaced and watch face re-buffed. Over 6 weeks. Now, in month 10 of owning it, the wrist clasp broke. I am by no means an aggressive consumer or wearer of watches... It speaks more to the poor quality than anything. And good luck getting help from the Brooklyn-based customer service department.

• Did the image onsite match the product? Yes
• Did the product fit true to size? Yes
• How is the quality of the product? Poor

My purchase for Christmas came quickly and at a great SPECIal Price. However, it came broken. Stem was off. So I notified O after Cmas when the gift was opened. They sent out a replacement BEFORE I had to send the orginal one back. HOw AWESOME of O.co. They sent an apology and shipping info to ship back and all that was needed. My email to O customer Help was anwered within a day. I could not be more pleased. Ordering online ,well sometimes you don't know what the item will look like or work. SO FAR...O's customer Service solves the problem quickly and honorably ! I haven't been upset with Overstock yet ! Thank you

• How did the image on site compare with the actual product? looks the same
• How accurate was the sizing? I knew the sizing would be ok. Bought from Stuhrling before
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. Excellant and great looks on a guy.

I really like this watch. It has a great look and get a lot of looks, but... I brought the watch to wear on my vacation to the Bahamas. After I went swimming in the ocean, I found that the watch was not totaly waterproof. The water that I was in was not more than four feet, and I swam for about three hours. The watch still works (keeps time), now it fogs up on the inside.

I have been wearing this watch for over 6 months now. Keeps very accurate time. It is very sturdy and impressive looking. I really like this watch and woudln't hesitate buying another from this company.

This watch was a gift to my 30 something son who is a watch fiend....unfortunately the band did not last very long and needed to be replaced.

• How did the image on site compare with the actual product? exactly
• How accurate was the sizing? exact
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. Not what I would have expected

I bought this watch for my husband and he absolutely loved it. It's such a great value for the price. He loved the stylish big face and the vertical links on the band. Looks much more expensive than it was. It also came in a very nice box. Very happy with this purchase!

• How did the image on site compare with the actual product? Same
• How accurate was the sizing? Accurate
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. Great Quality

Wish I would of read the other reviews before purchasing... The first watch I received was very damaged and pieces went flying everywhere when he tried to put it on. I took it to a repair store thinking my husband has damaged it, but no, the band was defective. One very expensive trip later, I went home and returned the watch for a new identical one. I like the second watch, thought we did have to have two links taken out since the band is rather large.

Stylish plus rugged. The band has this great push button release. Looks like it will hold up better than my Invica Pro Diver watch which hand difficulty keeping accurate time and the push pins in the band kept bending. Invica service is expensive and not very customer friendly. great watch.

Fast shipping, and perfect packaging. I am very pleased with my experience. He loved the watch.

came in beautiful box, good looking, no problems so far

I bought this watch for my 31 y/o "Hip" Boyfriend (Im 39) I was a little worried by the reviews here that it would be a "Mature Gentleman's" watch. No Way! This watch is BEAUTIFUL, Cool equisite detailing. The wavy face on this watch is very well made . This whole watch is Expensive looking, classy and elegant. Great for a night on the town, and HOT for a sunday Brunch. Not too Big and Round,it does raise a bit high from wrist ,but that just adds to its elegance. Im sooooo happy I went with this watch. HE LOVED IT !! He thought I paid $$$$ for it =) The Box it comes in is very impressive,satin lined with certificate of authenticity.

For $200 you will not find a more beautiful watch than this in my opinion. I've had mine for a couple of years now and wear it daily. I have had some problems with it. Every time I have had an issue I've contacted Stuhrling's customer service and have been able to send it in to get fixed at no cost. This company stands behind their products. I couldn't be more pleased with this watch and I am complimented on it on a regular basis. Thank you Stuhrling!

I received my watch in approximately 10 days, and it the packaging was nothing short of elegant. The face is very handsome, and the case thickness is absolutely perfect. Although, now that I've had it for 2 days, the band broke. Unfortunately there is nothing I can do but get a refund from overstock, and Stuhrling is less than helpful when it has come to this issue. I am extremely pleased with the aesthetic appearance, but the faulty band is a rather irritating reality. I would hope to believe that is just a freak-accident, but because of the issue I have had, I can't give my watch more than 3 stars.

Well, my husband needed a new watch and he is actually very conservative and very picky. I saw this watch and thought it looked so pretty. Well, I ordered it and HE LOVES IT! To me it was a little larger than I expected but it looks terrific. The box that the watch comes in is spectacular. It is almost the size of a wine bottle box. The watch is even presented on a little "leather" pillow. Would be wonderful gift box. So, we are both pleased. He has worn it in the pool once, no problem. Will let you know if that changes- but I think it is good-to-go.

This is a great watch. Well made and looks great!_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

I got this watch as a graduation gift. Beautiful watch high quality, very nice presentation box. Just as shown on Overstock. Prompt shipping. Thanks for the great shopping at home experience. I will be back.

Awesome watch. Got this for my boyfriend as a college graduation gift. He LOVED it. The packaging was so nice and classy too. A GREAT gift for any deserving man.

Arrived fast and it looks fantastic. Another successful order at Overstock.

This watch has an excellent fit and finish! I purchased it because it has the appearance of a watch that costs much more. It keeps very good time and is easy to use. I have an Omega and right now I'm wearing this one most often.

great watch! recommend for anyone to buy. .