This was my first piece of "jewelry" I've purchased on the site... I have to say that overall I'm impressed... It's well constructed and seams to be holding up to daily abuse very well... The ring itself is very strong and a bit difficult to get the 1st key on... But with a little work all my key's are securely in place... As for why only 4 stars... I personally think that it should have been just a little bit more for the price... I'd still buy it again, I'd just wait for a better sale...