I'm rating this product as excellent because it is as nice as it looks in the picture. I am very pleased with it. The only problem I had was although it was packed in very well and seemed to be secured a price was broken. The loop at the top that connects it to the chain was cracked in 3 pieces and could not be fixed. We had to go to Home Depot and find a piece, spray paint it and make do. I liked it so much I didn't want to return it.