Bought a bunch of these as dining room chairs for my office kitchen area (with the tabouret dining tables). They are comfortable, sturdy, but a bit too firm. The pre-drilled holes for the cushion attachment did not always line up, so some screws had to be omitted when putting together.
I probably would have given "excellent" across the board, but one of the chairs arrived with a big dent and paint chipped off of it. Overstock took care of it in time, but it seems that every time I order something online I have some issue. Maybe I just have bad mo-jo.
I ordered two sets of four Padded Silver Tabouret chairs. They are great, not high ended looking, but offer my guests lots of casual seating. Our family is smaller and we find them comfortable, but I worry when we have a large guest their butt will get stuck in these chairs. Upon arrival, one from each box was damaged (bent) and Overstock quickly sent replacements chairs. Putting the seats on was a bit of a challenge as others have remarked.