I have nothing but trouble with the 57"X74" shade since I bought it. The twine that makes the shade pull up and down has broken 3 times. I have replaced it with 2 different kinds of twine but it still continues to fray and break. I finally took it down and will probably throw it away. Unfortunately it matches 2 smaller shades in the same room so I will we loosing 3 window coverings. I think the problem is that the shade is so heavy it stresses the twine to the max.