The filling of the cushion sucks. The filling material would be good for a throw pillow or stuffed animal but is a poor choice for a seat cushion. I was expecting something more like the classic cotton futon-style cushion typically used for a papasan chair. With this cushion you can feel the frame of the chair through the cushion - not comfortable at all.
At the price, I was expecting less. The fabric quality is good to above average. The tufts appear to be glued, something I'm pretty sure will fail in time. I was not expecting button tufts but I suppose for the price I expected something other than glue.
After 30 years, I decided to replace the original cushion that came with the papasan chair I had bought in Okinawa. When it came, and given the time reccommeded to allow it reshape, I sat down and it felt like a cloud! I think this cushion may be even better than the original one I bought! And compared to other sites I looked at, the price can't be beat.