For whatever reason, this set came tarnished. The wrought iron which is usually black has areas of which silver comes through. I thought about returning it, but have not done so yet. Otherwise, the set itself is quite nice.

This is an ok set - but it is much smaller than I expected. The quality is ok - but we are using this with our outdoor fireplace and for the price I expected it to have longer handles. Probably just fine for indoors.