Unfortunately, I did not pay attention to the color offered. Too light to be a good liner. I believe a liner should have definition. If one does not mind that, I guess the quality is fine. I would not return cosmetics, therefore, kept them. However, would not purchase same if I had known that the color is that light. L'Oreal makes good products; therefore, thought I cold not go wrong, but was mistaken.

• How did the image on site compare with the actual product? fine
• How accurate was the on site description of the product? yes
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. The quality is good

I always buy this lip liner at ***** and it is so expensive!! I love it since it stays on and you never have to sharpen the pencile. Now i know where to get it at an affordable price and 4 at a time! Thank you overstock