I must rate this as poor only due to the fact that the actual color of the lipstick on Overstock is pictured as a rosey tone. What I received is totally different, and is BLAH at best. It is more of a tan, nude tone that has no semblence of pink or rose in it. If that is what you are looking for, don't buy this one! It looks like a nice product otherwise. I will have to find a friend to gift it to.