i ordered this for my fiance for our 4 year anniversary. It is such a dissapointment. The lighter looks NOTHING like in the picture, and it isnt even made of metal, its plastic..... and already faulty. The tray is okay i guess, i didnt have any expectations for it really, so it neither enthralled me nor dissapointed. As for the candle... well its really hard to mess that one up... so its okay as well. Overall, i was very upset with the lighters poor quality and ruined the whole gift for me and my fiance... now i have to go buy him a new one that is better. I WOULD NOT buy this for anyone who knows anything about cigars, lighters, smoking, ect.