purchased this for my husband as a christmas gift. he absolutely loves it.

• How accurate was the sizing? yes
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. good
• Was the product free of any manufacturer defects? yes

I bought this as a Christmas gift for my husband. It is his first humidor so we don't have anything to compare it to. However, this one has been great for him! Very beautiful!

The humidor is beautiful, and works well. It was not completely seasoned, but was slightly pre-seasoned, so seasoning took less than a week. I agree with a previous reviewer who mentions that the humidifier runs a bit too moist. I'm still fiddling with humidification to find the right balance. And as usual, the analog hygrometer is mostly decoration. Definitely worth the price, and far more attractive than others out there in this price range. Plan for another $20-30 for a digital hygrometer and maybe an alternate humidifier. The cutter works fine and has a nice heavy feel in the hand.

Very good product, great price and would recommend this to a friend.

The only humidor I could compare it with was one overstock sent me which happened to be the wrong item. Although that one was nice, it was only a plain cherrywood humidor with the gauge on the inside. Overstock handled the wrong shipment completely and fully to my satisfaction and when I received this humidor I was extremely satisfied with the quality and design of this one. It was just as it was described. My son-in-law absolutely loved it for his birthday.

This was my first purchase at overstock. I was a bit worried about buying a humidor online without being able to see it or touch it. But. I ordered it, recieved it and it was perfect. Even better then what I thought. The value is way better then what these humidors go for in private shops. I was very pleased with it and the the way it came in. No dents or nicks and as described. I would definetly recommend this humidor and recommend overstock to anyone who is looking to shop at a reasonable price for quality merchandise. THANKS OVERSTOCK!

First and foremost I have to say that this humidor is fantastic. The overall look of it is very appealing. The glass top and upper tray is nice for displaying your top shelf smokes to the curious and the lower storage area is quite spacious. The little foam pieces that help hold the cedar dividers in place is a little flimsy, but work well. The hygrometer works well and is about as accurate as any analogue one can be. Though it is a shame that its dial is plastic and not metal. The humidifier it ships with is well suited to the size of the box, if not maybe a bit big as its a bit too humid (it sits on the high end of about 76) so you may want to buy two smaller humidifiers to better regulate it. Also it was pre seasoned so I didn't need to take the time to do so myself which was a plus! Only negatives are that there isn't much room to put a digital hygrometer in the box in a neat way, I just have it sitting in the top tray. Plus the included cutter while good (and with a lifetime warranty, you just pay the postage) I would rather have paid an extra ten bucks and picked myself up another Xikar Xi2. No postage on those, just take it into your tobacco store if you have a problem, and they'll fix it or replace it.