For the price paid, I could have purchased higher quality desserts from a local bakery. I got this as a valentine's day gift for my husband who loves dessert. The first month, he got a blueberry blizzard coffee cake. This was good and worth the money.. Rugalach was the dessert for the second month. Not great, but I didn't feel like I had been ripped off. Month three was cookies. Some were just plain sugar cookies (that weren't even that good). Some had white chocolate or cherries. If my husband didn't enjoy his monthly surprise so much, I would have canceled after this installment. Next up was a chocolate peanut butter pie. I thought this was good but a little too rich. Didn't keep well either. I think we threw away over half of it. For month five we got a tin of brownies. Some were regular, some had a sweet cream cheese drizzle. These were quite tasty, but not worth the price paid. Last of all, we received a key lime coffee cake. This was nasty. Two bites and it went in the trash. Short of the long: the delivery part is cool. But it's undoubtedly overpriced for what you get.

• How accurate was the sizing? fair
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. acceptable
• Was the product free of any manufacturer defects? yes

There needs to be a choice for ZERO stars. While the pictures are nice, and their website www xxxxxxx specifically bolds the statement that they have the "freshest and most mouth-watering desserts" it is the complete opposite. The first month we received dry brownies that were slightly smashed and crumbling. The second month was a small dry marble bundt cake (no way would it serve 8-12 even if you wanted to) and just now received white chocolate chip cookies that were (you guessed it) dry. Hard to believe that they are getting away with selling a dozen or so average-at-best brownies and a few more cookies for xxxxx a pop. This is a great racket for them, but hopefully I can post this review in enough places that they won't take anymore people in. DON"T ORDER this - and please note this has nothing to do with Overstock other than they act as another storefront for this club place.

Gave this to my father-in-law for Christmas. He and my mother-in-law fight over the last bites each month! They love it. Great gift with super quality treats.

My brother just got his first one and he called me and told me they were EXCELLANT