The cutter and travel bag are perfect. The humidor is so so, perhaps for this price range, there is nothing you can really complain.

My husband and I was very pleased. I should of ordered the smaller size but my husband will never run out of space.

• How accurate was the sizing? very
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. looks very nice...you can put it anywhere
• Was the product free of any manufacturer defects? yes

Only thing that coud be improved IMO is that the humidifier should attach to the humidor with velcro, not sticky tape, as it has to be removed for refilling periodially. Nice cutter included. A high value purchase imo.

This was a Father's Day present for my husband. He had seen a humidor in a local tobacco shop but I knew I could trust Overstock to have a quality product at a reasonable price. The items arrived quickly, and were packed extremely well. There were several steps to prepare the humidor and the instructions were easy to follow. My husband especially liked the two addition items that came with the humidor; the cigar cutter and the black leather personal cigar pouch. The beautiful wood humidor has kept his cigars fresh since the day he began using it. It was a perfect gift.

The humidor was great! Better than I thought it would be. My boyfriend loved it- especially the leather case and cutter. Very nice gift!

I purchased this humidore for my sweetheart and am very pleased with my purchase. It arrived quickly and is a beautiful piece of furniture. I followed the directions for calibrating and installing the hygrometer and humidifier. I was very pleased that it included two additional gifts: a cigar cutter and a traveling case. I heartily recommend this product to anyone looking for a great humidore.

I ordered this for my boyfriend and he loved it. It came with detailed instructions on how it works. The only thing was, it came missing the cutter. I did not find out right away because he didn't know it came with one. If you order, make sure you check your box completely when you receive it.

As bargains go, this is one of the best. Not only did the description and images show exactly what I received, they did not do the item justice. This humidor and the extra accessories are top quality, I would have expected to pay much more for any one piece, but all together was much more than I expected in quality. It is obvious the pride went into the craftsmanship of the wood work and fitments. The top closes with a nice snug fit and there is ample room for a moderate supply of your favorite cigars. The stainless steel cutter is beyond any cutter I have used in design and quality, it is now my daily cigar cutting tool!One could say I am 'beyondelated'!

While I didn't do a lot of comparative shopping, I was very happy with the qualify of the humidor and other accessories included. It products were packaged to avoid breakage, which is a bid deal considering the way most shippers handle packages. The instructions are clear and easy to understand. The package shipped very quickly. I'd recommend it to anyone who enjoys the occasional cigar.

Good packaging but slightly damaged on the corners a little disappointed. The plastic cutter is worthless... my husband used it twice and it broke. It also comes with the stainless steel cutter which is wonderful. Complete Cigar Smoker Combo overall nice and a good starter......

I purchased the cigar combo for my husband for Christmas, and he was very surprised that I chose this package as a gift. He loved the humidor and put it to use immediately. I also purchased some cigars for him and he was floored. It was a great value for such a great gift. Would definitely recommend this package for the beginner cigar smoker who needs some good supplies to start off with.

I thought it was a great deal and looks very nice. My husband really loved it. I just wish it had a knob to open it because it is a very tight fit as it should be. All in all it was a great buy.