This product is okay. Not great, not awful. It is leather but it's very cheap. I don't expect the case to remain unscratched for much longer if I keep throwing it in my overstuffed purse. It is also a little tricky to open with one hand. There is not enough weight in the cover to make it easy to flip open the way you would a cell phone.
I really like the features it provides: protection for my Nano, access to the headphone jack and computer jack (can't use both at the same time because there's a small strap at the bottom to keep the iPod in place and it covers up one or the other depending on how the iPod is positioned), ability to clip it to something or hang it from your neck, nice appearance if you're not looking too closely. I like the ability to rotate and remove the clip but I am a little concerned about it breaking if I'm not careful as it sticks out a lot.
This product does what I need it to do. I would not recommend it to a friend, however, because I would encourage them to get something of higher quality unless their needs were like mine. I gave this product 3 stars because it offers some great features but it is very cheap. I'm fine with my purchase but I can see myself buying a nicer case in the next year or two.