Positives and comments: Water resistant, fits true to size, casual and formal, adjustable/ detachable hood, front storm flap with zipper, buttons sewn on correctly, hits me at the knees and I'm 5'5", Medium fits me well and I'm 36-28-36, sleeves are normal length, and it looks slimming.
Negatives: The lining attracts pet hair (static guard helps), pull-cord on hood looks a bit like middle school: simply too long and drab (they could've made a shorter version with elastics), buttons are of low quality and the edges of which the thread is sewn through are sharp: this is why the thread breaks off of them, with constant friction... I could imagine what happens when you put it in the wash (I plan to replace the buttons with better ones), when i zip up the storm flap (the thing that looks like a turtleneck underneath) it is a tad bit tight at the neck, and I wouldn't say that the coat is stylish in the a la mode sense, but it should take you through many years of neutral fashion.