The other reviews I found to be true -- cute but the front of the shoes crowded my toes and the heel constantly slipped out -- and not in a good way. Ended up donating shoes.

• How did the color on site compare with the actual product? Okay
• Please tell us about the quality of the product. Sturdy, but odd fit
• How accurate was the sizing? Not very

These run a bit wide compared to others of the same brand. They were adorable and I attempted several types of inserts before giving them up to the consignment shop. My foot is narrow and long (9.5 A) so others may not have the same issues. They were simply gorgeous so I am disappointed they didn't work for me.

• Did the color match the color displayed onsite? Yes
• How is the quality of the product? Excellent
• Did the product fit true to size? No

These shoes are amazing. They are comfortable and fit perfect. There is a velcro strap to make the heel custom fit to your foot so it's hard to go wrong on the size. They aren't quite like wearing your most comfy slippers, but I never feel like I'm wearing dress shoes. I could walk all day in these, and could probably wear them to Disneyworld and not complain!

These shoes are so cute that I took a chance after reading various reviews on sizing issues. I sized up half a size as recommended. I will note that I am probably somewhere in between an 8.5 and 9, depending on the shoe. Since I have a wider foot, I'm a medium width, but find some shoes to be a little tight at the toes, I went for the 9.5 and they are great! A perfect fit. The ability to tighten the heel strap keeps them on with no problems. I would say that if you have a fairly narrow foot, this might not be the shoe for you.

These would be wonderful shoes, if they fit.I followed the advice printed in the item description that says the shoes run a half size small, and thus ordered a half size up -- they are at least a full size too large!The shoes would be lovely, if they fit -- they're nicely padded at the heel, the footbeds are gloriously padded, but they're huge.

J-41 Women's 'Sevilla' Mary Jane Heels are super cute but they run way too small, I'd say at least a full size. Nothing else matters if they don't fit.

Don't listen to the "Please note: shoes run a 1/2 size small. We suggest ordering a 1/2 size larger than usual" that is listed at the end of the description. Order a half size smaller than what you normally get

These shoes, like all J-41's, are cute, stylish and comfy. Not to mention well-made. Sadly, this style runs big and the heel slipped to the point that I had to send them back. I wear a 7.5 and tried the 8. If they have a 7, I'll give that a try -- they are cute enough that it's worth the trouble.