While this pillow wasn't exactly like the one I was replacing, it is a terrific pillow. It has just the right amount of support for my neck and shoulder and is enabling me to have a restful night's sleep. The pillows came very quickly and needed very little breaking in. It was a great buy
I can't say a lot about how they hold up for everyday us since these are not pillows we sleep on - I bought them to use with pillow shams to top the bed. However, I've had them for a few years though and they still look perfect! They are nice and fluffy and soft -- oh and they do get some functional use as our dog nestles in them pretty much daily! I'm pleased with them, a good purchase!