I bought these as a gift for my son and daughter-in-law. While I don't have first-hand experience, I can tell you that they are both pleased with the comfort level. One prefers a firmer pillow; the other a softer. Apparently, these pillows fit the bill for both!
I needed some large pillows to use to stuff some floor pillows acquired overseas. These worked fairly well, but were not quite as firm as I had hoped. For the price, the quality was good, and I had looked around quite a bit before purchasing these.
For the price, I was really impressed with the pillows. I they are sot, but not too soft. They hold their shape very well. My husband is pretty picky about his pillow and wasn't satisfied with a much more expensive pillow. He loves these!!