I'd give this an Excellent based on how cute it is, but the fabric is not that high quality in itself. It is a thin yet crispy cotton, not very soft and perhaps unwashed. I think a cold water wash will soften it. (The matching Antique Rose quilt set was soft. This looks great with that set.) There is a cute single tuck /semi-pleat in the center of side and bottom panels. The hem stitching is kind of big - about 5 stitches per inch. The hems are rolled (good). The seams are sergered and the white fabric that lies across the box spring is soft. The color is a 1/2 shade lighter than my comforter, but I actually like the slight variance; it seems more authentic and vintage and looks pretty. Obviously a different die lot. I was a bit alarmed when it arrived - it was packaged so that only white "under fabric" showed -none of the pattern was visible and I thought it was a mistake. That seemed rather odd. Maybe it was a fluke. I have ordered 2 more so I can use the fabric to widen my quilt (my mattress is 14" thick and the quilt was 4" too narrow), and maybe make a pillow. After a few washes, of course. So, clearly, it's not too bad!